Every vehicle is categorized by claims experience and given what is called a vehicle rate group. Typically 3 numbers representing: injury costs, repair costs, & theft/vandalism risk.
Logic does NOT apply here. Some Porsches are cheaper to insure than a civic si.
VW and hondas get horrible ratings, volvos and subarus get the best. Even though the latter are more expensive to repair, they are cheaper to insure.
When I was shopping for my car, initially I was looking at a ford escort zx2. Then what was to become my 328i came up and was actually a few hundred cheaper to insure. Made my decision easy