Turns out it was a faulty valve cover gasket. With absolutely no hesitation, Rocco busted out a new gasket, opened her up and had it installed. As proof that he stands behind his work, he did it all free of charge!! What more can you ask for? I'll be keeping a close eye on it as instructed to make sure no more leaks. So far so good!
Thanks again Rocco, car feels and looks amazing!