Originally Posted by T.Dot_E30
There was a place in the GTA that sold them back in the day.
I bought two for my e30 and had them painted, they weren't perfect fitment and the metal was thinner than OEM. But for the price and considering that a rust free oem fender would probably harder to find they aren't too bad and much better than I had anyways.
This was 5+ years ago, so things might have changed.
I did the same thing ..Try a paint / body shop supplier ... I bought (2) new aftermarket steel fenders for my e30 318is for $80 / ea - I just wanted the lower section to use as patch repair panels. This was a few years ago, but I imagine they could still be available.