Thanks guys for your input. I really appreciate your advice.
Can you recommend a body shop that would paint the bumpers for less than $500 for the two of them? I've seen the painting process done before and it's definitely not worth $500. It will probably take 30 minutes of their time (as there is no disassembly or assembly), + the primer/paint/clear coating, etc. $500 sounds too much for the that, no?