I was in the same boat deciding what to get back in June. One ride in the M Coupe and I was sold.
It's a brute compared to the luxurious 335i and even the M3 but that's what I need now. I already have an E46 sedan and an X5 for family trips, etc.
It feels more like a sports car than any other BMW I've driven. Steering is tight and responsive and a small turning radius. Suspension is harsh but I've been using it as a daily driver since June and I'm used to it.
It's also a big plus that there's not many MCoupes around (only 1815 in North America).
Oh, and I forgot about the power. The S54 is amazing in this little car.
Last edited by Quickid; 10-04-2010 at 08:18 AM.