Depends if they're real or not. The BMW part number is stamped on the back, one of the spokes. Have him take a pic of it. Better yet, so he doesn't know what you're fishing for, ask him to take a pic of the back of every spoke of one of the rims. It's a normal price for a set of new replicas and a killer price for such clean OEMs (basically the price of 1.5 of ONE rim).