maXbimmer Forums

maXbimmer Forums (http://www.maxbimmer.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Discussion (http://www.maxbimmer.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   19" Wheels on E90/E92? (http://www.maxbimmer.com/forums/showthread.php?t=148189)

itrocks4u 01-13-2012 03:58 PM

19" Wheels on E90/E92?
 
Hi,

Just wanted to know if anyone here drives on 19" wheels on their car - E90/1/2/3? I've heard 19" have pretty hard drive and tend to bend/damage easily. Seeing our roads here in GTA would you suggest going with 19" or stick to 18" max?

Thanks.

Havok_2011 01-13-2012 04:03 PM

19" are common on E90's and E92's

You won't have any issues until you get up to 20" which will usually require a fender roll and spacers.

I have OEM 19" rims and have no issues. Most of the guys in the E92 club run 19" There is the occasional nut that does 20"

Bent/damaged rims have little to do with it being 19" and all to do with how cheap they are made (what company you go with).

Quality comes with the price tag.

itrocks4u 01-14-2012 02:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Havok_2011 (Post 1543793)
19" are common on E90's and E92's

You won't have any issues until you get up to 20" which will usually require a fender roll and spacers.

I have OEM 19" rims and have no issues. Most of the guys in the E92 club run 19" There is the occasional nut that does 20"

Bent/damaged rims have little to do with it being 19" and all to do with how cheap they are made (what company you go with).

Quality comes with the price tag.

Havok then why do so many people say that it's a lot stiffer and harder and easy to damage rims. How do you feel about it? For daily driver, would you recommend 18 or 19 (no rfts ofcourse)

dbworld4k 01-14-2012 02:26 AM

19s are fine...

Havok_2011 01-15-2012 02:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by itrocks4u (Post 1543875)
Havok then why do so many people say that it's a lot stiffer and harder and easy to damage rims. How do you feel about it? For daily driver, would you recommend 18 or 19 (no rfts ofcourse)

Who are all these people you are referring to that tell you this?? 19" for daily use is completely fine. Perhaps they are basing this on the fact that the larger the rim, the thinner the rubber, so a rougher ride when hitting bumps etc. But 19" don't create a rough ride on an E92. BMW sells you these cars on 19" if you get the package. Another major factor is if you have runflats or not. Runflats are a rougher ride, but they will be a saving grace if your tires ever pop.

20" is another story as I mentioned previously.

If you posted this up at the E90post forums they would tell you the same. 19" aren't a problem. Get a good set is all I recommend. OEM's are strong but a tad heavy from what people say, but I have 10" OEM and they are great. You could always go to Tires23 in Mississauga and look into a good set of rims. Those guys are great, and can get anything you want. Been dealing with them for over 10 years now.

BMWdouche 01-15-2012 04:49 PM

I had this dilemma picking mine so I'll share my thought process:

- 19's are more expensive + need more expensive Tyres so 18's are a cheaper option
- 19's in some cases WILL bend more easy but as Havok said it matters about the quality. Cheap 19's will bend more easily than cheap 18's. OEMs are solid and shouldn't be a problem (really depends on where you live, I lived downtown and didn't want to risk it)
- 19's will be a little firmer because of thinner rubber, again depends on the roads you run.
- Lastly, this is gonna cause a ruckus I'm sure, but my research indicated that running 18's would help on the racetrack because of lower unsprung weight and less rotational mass. Stock M3 rims are 18".

So I bought staggered 18's......it was mostly because they were cheaper though.. lol

EDIT: Also I like the way 18's look on an E90.. 19's look too big/flashy for my tastes

itrocks4u 01-15-2012 06:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Havok_2011 (Post 1544039)
Who are all these people you are referring to that tell you this?? 19" for daily use is completely fine. Perhaps they are basing this on the fact that the larger the rim, the thinner the rubber, so a rougher ride when hitting bumps etc. But 19" don't create a rough ride on an E92. BMW sells you these cars on 19" if you get the package. Another major factor is if you have runflats or not. Runflats are a rougher ride, but they will be a saving grace if your tires ever pop.

20" is another story as I mentioned previously.

If you posted this up at the E90post forums they would tell you the same. 19" aren't a problem. Get a good set is all I recommend. OEM's are strong but a tad heavy from what people say, but I have 10" OEM and they are great. You could always go to Tires23 in Mississauga and look into a good set of rims. Those guys are great, and can get anything you want. Been dealing with them for over 10 years now.

I guess that makes sense, I'm thinking 19" staggered, 235/35/19 and 265/30/19 for E90.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BMWdouche (Post 1544048)
I had this dilemma picking mine so I'll share my thought process:

- 19's are more expensive + need more expensive Tyres so 18's are a cheaper option
- 19's in some cases WILL bend more easy but as Havok said it matters about the quality. Cheap 19's will bend more easily than cheap 18's. OEMs are solid and shouldn't be a problem (really depends on where you live, I lived downtown and didn't want to risk it)
- 19's will be a little firmer because of thinner rubber, again depends on the roads you run.
- Lastly, this is gonna cause a ruckus I'm sure, but my research indicated that running 18's would help on the racetrack because of lower unsprung weight and less rotational mass. Stock M3 rims are 18".

So I bought staggered 18's......it was mostly because they were cheaper though.. lol

EDIT: Also I like the way 18's look on an E90.. 19's look too big/flashy for my tastes

I see your points. I highly doubt I'll track the 328. Cost is a major factor for me as well. The cost of 18" square setup is almost the same as 19" staggered setup that I'm thinking right now (maybe $150 more). This is because the 19" are second-hand rims and in good condition. If it wasn't for these rims, I'd definitely go 18"s cause of budget.

dbworld4k 01-15-2012 06:12 PM

19s will always look better on the E9x. Heck, they look great on the E46. I find 18s are the upper limit on E36s, but anything beyond that 19s are a must.

Jim .E. 01-15-2012 07:12 PM

I have 18's on my E90 and I can tell you right now they're a bit small, 19's minimum on a E9X

I have a good meaty tire so it fills the gap well - but its still too small.

BMWdouche 01-15-2012 08:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jim .E. (Post 1544065)
I have 18's on my E90 and I can tell you right now they're a bit small, 19's minimum on a E9X

I have a good meaty tire so it fills the gap well - but its still too small.

ya'll are crazy!!!!

Havok_2011 01-16-2012 10:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by itrocks4u (Post 1544058)
I guess that makes sense, I'm thinking 19" staggered, 235/35/19 and 265/30/19 for E90.

I have a staggered setup as well, looks best on our cars rather than a square setup. Go for it man!! Will look great :)

Havok_2011 01-16-2012 10:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BMWdouche (Post 1544048)
I had this dilemma picking mine so I'll share my thought process:

- 19's are more expensive + need more expensive Tyres so 18's are a cheaper option
- 19's in some cases WILL bend more easy but as Havok said it matters about the quality. Cheap 19's will bend more easily than cheap 18's. OEMs are solid and shouldn't be a problem (really depends on where you live, I lived downtown and didn't want to risk it)
- 19's will be a little firmer because of thinner rubber, again depends on the roads you run.
- Lastly, this is gonna cause a ruckus I'm sure, but my research indicated that running 18's would help on the racetrack because of lower unsprung weight and less rotational mass. Stock M3 rims are 18".

So I bought staggered 18's......it was mostly because they were cheaper though.. lol

EDIT: Also I like the way 18's look on an E90.. 19's look too big/flashy for my tastes

I agree with everything you said (except the last comment, 19" look best on the E90's :) ), including tracking on smaller rims will give you better results. 19" on the track is not ideal. I am currently working on a setup for a set of track rims. Want to go 17" since they fit on my car for the track, or will find a set of 18".

I tracked last season on my 19" OEM rims.....not ideal, not only because they are 19", but because they were runflats and OEM rims= heavy.

I expect my track setup to make a big difference next season. :)

Havok_2011 01-16-2012 10:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BMWdouche (Post 1544075)
ya'll are crazy!!!!

yessum we iz.

itrocks4u 01-16-2012 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Havok_2011 (Post 1544138)
I have a staggered setup as well, looks best on our cars rather than a square setup. Go for it man!! Will look great :)

Alright - almost convinced lol.

What tire size are you running on the 19"s? I was thinking 235/35 F and 265/30 R. BMW says that's not possible and 225/35 F and 255/30 R is better. Both obviously for XI models.

Any thoughts? What difference does that make?

Jim .E. 01-17-2012 02:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BMWdouche (Post 1544075)
ya'll are crazy!!!!

not really.

https://fbcdn-sphotos-a.akamaihd.net...83575821_n.jpg

18x8.5 on 225/45 all around...was small.

now on (still 18x8.5 rims) 225/45 front and 255/45 rear. Looks a little more flush in the rear

https://fbcdn-sphotos-a.akamaihd.net...41746111_n.jpg


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:11 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.