PDA

View Full Version : Getting new 328xi on Sat...should I change tires?


Rockblock
02-25-2010, 09:30 PM
Hey folks, got a quick question: my new 2010 328xi arrives on Sat and it comes with Summer performance RFT...given that we're running out of winter soon, I was wondering whether or not I could drive the car as is and buy winter tires next season...for a mth left, I wouldn't want to spend extra $ until next winter, unless it's a must...any thoughts? Thx

Stephanie
02-26-2010, 09:09 AM
I honestly wouldnt bother. Being that it's an "xi", you should be fine.

My boyfriend's dad has a 530xi that he just picked up this year too and he didn't bother changing the tires either (mostly just to test the performance to see if he could get away with avoiding winters...), the big snow storm this week was his first real encounter in the snow and he was just fine!

My pops has a AWD Benz too, never bothers to put on winter tires...

Just take it easy to see how the car reacts in the snow the first time around and gauge it from there... But I would wait til next season for snow tires (or not get them at all)...

And PS: congrats on the new ride!!! *th-up*

Blackedout95
02-26-2010, 11:08 AM
I drive an xi myself with all seasons on the stock rims for winter at the moment as they came with the car. I keep a set of 18 inch hyper black CSL's for summer :)

Next year will be snow's because frankly they are the best for the season xi or not. I mean come on dude its like $1k, if you cant float that without feeling a pinch you shouldnt be in a 2010 :rolleyes:

Just because you can slide by on them doesnt mean you should.

T.Dot_E30
02-26-2010, 11:27 AM
If you were looking to buy used tires, now is a good time to buy.

If you were going to buy new, might as well await till next year.

Italia311
02-26-2010, 11:49 AM
Congrats on new car.

I didn't put winters on mine and it isn't AWD. Its fine. Just gotta take it easy...

MarkD
02-26-2010, 12:09 PM
Hey folks, got a quick question: my new 2010 328xi arrives on Sat and it comes with Summer performance RFT...given that we're running out of winter soon, I was wondering whether or not I could drive the car as is and buy winter tires next season...for a mth left, I wouldn't want to spend extra $ until next winter, unless it's a must...any thoughts? Thx

I wouldn't be driving in this weather in summer performance tires, is that really what the car would be delivered with? You should look for some cheap used winter wheels/tires to use till you can afford something better. One small collision and you will wish you did.

Some of the other advice I see hewre is not very good.

BimmerDriver
02-26-2010, 06:12 PM
Being it an XI I wouldn't worry about it handling wise, don't think you'd have trouble losing control of her. I'd be more worried about stopping distances which are dramatically reduced with snow tires. We're almost done the season so I guess you can get away by just leaving some extra space between you and the next guy

spoony_prelude
02-26-2010, 06:20 PM
I agree with the fact that it would be stupid to spend 50+gs on a car then cheap out on winter tires. Remember awd helps you with accelerating, not braking. So I would invest in new or even used snow tires, check kijiji!

Like Mark said, all it takes is one small collision for you to wish you have spent the 500-1000 on tires!

Jay

Mystikal
02-26-2010, 06:34 PM
I'm not so sure that the majority of you read that it's coming with summer tires. If it was a non-sport on all-seasons, sure, go nuts. But on summers?

If you can't afford to work from home and/or find another way to get around on snow days, you HAVE to buy different tires. You will not be able to stop or turn in any reasonable manner.

damameke
02-26-2010, 09:39 PM
I'm not so sure that the majority of you read that it's coming with summer tires. If it was a non-sport on all-seasons, sure, go nuts. But on summers?

If you can't afford to work from home and/or find another way to get around on snow days, you HAVE to buy different tires. You will not be able to stop or turn in any reasonable manner.

Jay read OP's post. only logical advise...get the snow tire..

I have an XI and runnning all season .

Rockblock
02-26-2010, 11:07 PM
Thx all for all the advise...I managed to convince the dealer to replace the summers w/all season...problem solved ! (unfortunately I couldn't convince him to replace the steering wheel with a sports one...*mumble*)

Thx again for all your feedback !

MTREEDAT
02-26-2010, 11:14 PM
I always found that brand new tires were always very good the first year......no matter what they were. I'm sure the first year they will stick in snow, but the second and third year, you're gonna have wanted snows.

It depends on the driver too.......I could drive most anything and it wouldn't really bother me but not what I would send my family out in.

chenx15
02-27-2010, 06:16 AM
first off congratulations on the new beautiful machine. according to the weather network you will not need the winter tires anymore. but to be safe, i would buy them even if you just get used rims and winter tires. don't go cheap on safety the lesson can be extremely expensive.

Daddy
03-02-2010, 04:01 PM
You people who have not driven the summer RFT's in winter are just nuts giving the advice. The summer rubbers on ice and snow are downright dangerous.

I have an xi and sure, it's easy enough to get going, but stopping is terrible. Any amount of snow or ice and the summer tires are like hockey pucks.

Personal experience. I have done it and have lived to tell you the story.

theblue
03-02-2010, 04:34 PM
LOL @ all the people in this thread advising that AWD will make up for snow tires.

how exactly does AWD make a car stop faster?

I run all seasons in the winter because they came with the car and I'm decent driver and I have a short commute. I wouldn't run summer tires because with some snow on the ground it quickly becomes as issue of not being able to stop.

If you're planning on driving this car next winter then why not buy some used snow tires / wheels now while they are cheaper (towards the end of the season)

MarkD
03-02-2010, 06:51 PM
LOL @ all the people in this thread advising that AWD will make up for snow tires.

how exactly does AWD make a car stop faster?

I run all seasons in the winter because they came with the car and I'm decent driver and I have a short commute. I wouldn't run summer tires because with some snow on the ground it quickly becomes as issue of not being able to stop.

If you're planning on driving this car next winter then why not buy some used snow tires / wheels now while they are cheaper (towards the end of the season)

Yup it's pretty weird what people said here. I can't beleive that the mods didn't remove some of those useless posts with bad advice. Whoops look like even a "mod" gave some bad advice. I guess talk is cheap here.

ShortShifter
03-07-2010, 04:47 PM
I have an E91 XI and I would definately recommend winter tires. It is very hard to stop and turn in bad weather with the stock tires that come with the sport package. Its like driving on ski's! Be safe and buy winter tires!

golden_boy
03-08-2010, 09:55 AM
I have 07 sportpkg, summer tires and I drive in winter. It is not safe to drive on snow or icy conditions as I have tried it personally many times to test the x-drive. But it is safe to drive in winter when there is no snow on the ground especially when the roads are clear especially in areas like Mississauga since the roads are always clean.